−17%exam grades once the AI was removed
STRONG Turkey · high school maths
AI raised practice scores, then lowered exam scores
- What they did
- A field experiment with nearly 1,000 high-school maths students. Some practised with an ordinary ChatGPT-style tool, some with a version that gave hints rather than answers, and some with no AI.
- What they found
- Students with the ordinary tool scored 48% higher during practice, then 17% lower on the exam taken without it. The hint-giving version largely avoided the harm.
- Honest reading
- A large, well-designed experiment. It shows how AI is used matters more than whether it is used.
What to do at home: Ask your child to use AI for hints, not answers, and to explain the answer back to you.
Bastani et al., PNAS, 2025 · Original source
